Designed for a specific coaching framework 

Designed to be used with other frameworks 

Elements of fidelity measured

Number of Items

Scoring approach

Scoring guidance provided

Accessible

Includes measure of coachee behaviors

Options

Yes, no (framework)

Yes, no

Adherence, dosage, quality

#

Checklist, rating scale, rubric, notes

Yes, no, somewhat

Yes, no, somewhat

Yes, no

Coaching Fidelity Scale (Meadan et al., 2023) 

No

Yes

Adherence

12

Checklist

Somewhat

Somewhat

No

COaches Fidelity in Intervention DELivery 

Yes (BRIGHT Coaching) 

Yes

Adherence, quality

22

Rating scale (7 options)

Somewhat

Yes

No

KCAR-R, Tomchek et al 2024

Yes (Kentucky Caregiver Coaching Model)

No

Adherence, quality

7

Rubric

Yes

Yes

No

Parents Interacting with Children Guidelines Implementation Checklist

Yes (PIWI)

No

Adherence, quality

50

Checklist

No

Yes

Yes

Coaching Practices Rating Scale

Yes (Rush & Shelden) 

No

Adherence, quality

28

Checklist, rating scale, notes

Yes

Yes

No

Practice-Based Coaching Log

Yes (PBC)

No

Adherence, dosage

12

Checklist, notes

Somewhat

Yes

No

FGRBI Key Indicators Checklist

Yes (FGRBI)

No

Adherence, quality

12

Rubric (3: yes, partial, not observed)

Yes

Yes

No

Routines-Based Home Visit Checklist

Yes (Routines-Based Intervention)

No

Adherence

58

Checklist

Yes

Yes

No

Occupational Performance Coaching Fidelity Measure

Yes (OPC)

No

Adherence, quality

18 (10 critical, 4 client response, 4 distinguishing)

Rubric-Rating Scale (4: absent, low, moderate, high)

Yes

Yes

Yes